CN 11-5366/S     ISSN 1673-1530
“风景园林,不只是一本期刊。”

30分钟社区生活圈视角下的武汉市主城区绿色空间公平性评价

Equity Evaluation of Green Space in the Central Urban Area of Wuhan from the Perspective of 30-Minute Community Life Circle

  • 摘要:
    目的 全球城市化的加速不断带来各种城市病,城市自然环境被认为是改善居民福祉的重要因素,而多数城市中存在城市绿色空间资源分布不均的问题。将城市绿色空间分布与其他建成环境因素结合进行综合评价,可以全面了解自然资源的分布状况,有助于城市规划师和风景园林师提出更有针对性的改善策略。
    方法 使用基于高斯方程和网络生活圈阈值改进后的两步移动搜索(two-step floating catchment area, 2SFCA)法,对武汉市城市绿色空间资源配比情况进行评价,并结合社区建筑建成年限数据使用K-means聚类进行综合分析。
    结果 1)武汉市城市绿色空间资源分布存在显著失衡并呈现明显的空间效应,绿地与水景可达性分别呈现全局由中心向周边递增、局部团状聚集的特征。2)由聚类分析得到“供需匮乏—建筑老化”“供需匮乏—建筑较新”“供需充足—建筑老化”“供需充足—建筑较新”4种分类结果,发现社区建筑建成年限与城市绿色空间可达性整体呈现空间相关性,在局部地区呈现空间错位。3)政府主导的改善城市环境质量和增强居民交通能力的政策可以缓解城市绿色空间资源分配的不均衡。
    结论 验证了构建全面系统的可达性分析方法对于提升城市绿地空间公平性方面的重要性,并在老旧社区更新改造和可持续城市生态系统规划方面为城市管理者提供指导。

     

    Abstract:
    Objective The rapid pace of global urbanization has contributed to regional economic growth while simultaneously exacerbating various urban challenges. Urban green spaces (UGS) encompass a range of vegetated zones within urban areas, serving purposes such as greening, recreation, ecological conservation, and environmental enhancement. In a broader sense, UGS includes not only green zones but also rivers, water bodies, farmlands, gardens, forests, and other undeveloped lands. The unequal distribution of urban blue-green resources is a prevalent issue in many cities. Environmental justice, a comprehensive concept, entails the equitable distribution of resources between people and the environment. Whether residents incur significant costs to access urban natural resources and whether they have equal rights to such access are critical criteria for fairness evaluation. The two-step floating catchment area (2SFCA) method is a widely used spatial accessibility metric for evaluating the fairness of urban natural resource allocation. However, the traditional 2SFCA method often overlooks people’s travel preferences and the delineation of life circles. As a result, the accessibility evaluation is typically limited to a supply-demand perspective. In addition to the disparities in resource allocation, factors related to the built environment within communities must also be considered. Promoting a balanced spatial distribution of UGS is recognized as a critical strategy for addressing the issue of insufficient urban natural resources.
    Methods This research enhances the traditional two-step floating catchment area (2SFCA) method by integrating community attributes, blue-green space, and data on urban road network. Two key improvements are introduced: Incorporation of a distance decay threshold based on Gaussian equation and establishment of a 30-minute road network catchment area boundary. Three accessibility analysis methods — nearest distance method, buffer zone method, and network analysis method — are compared with the improved 2SFCA method. Additionally, based on the data on the age of community buildings, the distribution of urban green space resources is classified into four categories — “insufficient supply − aging buildings”, “insufficient supply − newer buildings”, “sufficient supply − aging buildings”, and “sufficient supply − newer buildings” — through the K-means clustering method. The classification results are visualized, and targeted recommendations are proposed for decision-makers. This research evaluates and visualizes the allocation of blue-green space resources and the clustering results for 1,025 communities within the central urban area of Wuhan. Based on these findings, tailored suggestions are provided for reference by decision-makers to guide future improvements.
    Results 1) The accessibility results obtained by the nearest distance method, the buffer zone method, and the network analysis method overestimate the distribution of urban green space resources in Wuhan. In contrast, the 2SFCA method more accurately reflects the imbalance in green space distribution. 2) The inequality in the allocation of urban green spaces displays significant spatial effects, with accessibility to greenery and water bodies increasing from the city center to the periphery, showing patterns of spatial clustering. More than half of the communities have lower-than-average accessibility to urban green spaces, and substantial differences in the supply-demand ratios of blue-green space exist across different regions. The integrated design and development of waterfront spaces can help mitigate the inequality in urban green space allocation to some extent, although excessively large water bodies can negatively impact the accessibility of green space. 3) The spatial distribution of communities across different categories is correlated with the urban development patterns. For aging communities with insufficient supply, a “squeeze-in” strategy to expand urban green space is recommended. For newer communities with insufficient supply, constructing pocket parks and removing barriers to park access are proposed. For aging communities with sufficient supply, landscape design that incorporates regional characteristics is suggested. For newer communities with sufficient supply, the planning of large parks and the strategic development of transportation routes are advised. Government-led initiatives to improve the quality of urban green space, along with policies aimed at enhancing residents’ mobility, can help alleviate green space inequality.
    Conclusion This research confirms the effectiveness of the improved 2SFCA method, which incorporates the daily travel behaviors of community residents, contributing to a more accurate representation of urban green space accessibility. The clustering results reveal a correlation between imbalances in urban green space distribution and urban development patterns, highlighting the importance of improving quality, providing policy guidance, and integrating regional culture to promote equity in green space allocation. In the context of urban renewal and transformation of aging communities, these findings may offer valuable insights for urban planners and researchers in the development of sustainable urban ecosystems.

     

/

返回文章
返回