CN 11-5366/S     ISSN 1673-1530
“风景园林,不只是一本期刊。”

园路铺装碳排放的生命周期评价

Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) of Carbon Emission of Garden Pavement

  • 摘要:
    目的 园林工程建造阶段是风景园林项目中碳足迹比重最大的部分,而园路铺装又是工程建造碳排放最多的分项。园路铺装从所需材料生产、工程建造及运输、使用维护以及材料回收再利用,各个阶段都产生了大量的碳排放。评估不同面层类型的园路铺装的生命周期碳排放量,可以为园林工程低碳减排研究提供理论依据。
    方法 以25种常见的园路铺装为例,构建园路铺装碳排放计算模型,厘清并计算各种园路铺装的生命周期碳排放量,并将结果进行归一分析和评价。
    结果 发现25种园路铺装中,生命周期内碳排放量最高的3种园路铺装是胶粘石路面、防腐木路面、石灰岩路面,碳排放量最低的3种园路铺装是混凝土路面、再生骨料混凝土路面和压膜艺术地坪。而将碳排放量进行单位面积年均处理后,碳排放量最高的3种园路铺装是胶粘石路面、透水混凝土砖路面、砂基透水砖路面,排放量最低的3种园路铺装是再生骨料混凝土路面、压膜艺术地坪和混凝土路面。
    结论 将碳排放量计算结果和具体实践结合进行分析评价,得出结论和策略:生命周期年均碳排放的高低与面层材料耐久性有较大的关系;混凝土作为路面铺装的基础性结构,在其上增加其他的面层作法会增加碳排放量;以高强、薄型材料作为园路铺装面层材料的路面,生命周期内所产生的碳排放较低;不同面层材料的寿命对年均碳排放量的影响高于其他因素,建议采用寿命长、强度高、结构薄型的铺装材料作为园路铺装材料,以实现低碳减排的策略。

     

    Abstract:
    Objective  With the proposal of the national “carbon neutrality” policy, various fields are exploring the mode of green, low-carbon and sustainable development. In the field of landscape architecture, a large amount of practical research has been carried out in the two aspects of enhancing urban resilience and reducing emissions and increasing sinks, both of which mainly focus on the qualitative research on study of the carbon footprints of landscape plants, soils, water bodies, green infrastructures, and green spaces over their entire life cycle. However, there exists less quantitative research on low carbon in the field of landscape engineering, which is mainly based on data from the architectural profession. The construction phase of landscape engineering is the largest part of the carbon footprint of landscape gardening, and pavement is the most carbon-emitting subcomponent of engineering construction. The current quantitative research on pavement is not enough to make a horizontal comparison of carbon emissions between different pavement materials, and there are certain deficiencies in both the parameter setting of pavement material specifications and the construction of the Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) model in the research process, which leads to the inability to accurately judge and select low-carbon materials. Therefore, in order to assess the carbon emissions of garden pavements with different types of surface layers in pavement projects over the life cycle of such pavements, and to provide theoretical basis for the research on low-carbon emission reduction in landscape engineering, this research takes the life cycle of garden pavement projects as the theoretical basis, adopts the carbon emission factor method, constructs a calculation model for carbon emissions of garden pavements, and then calculates and screens out the optimal “carbon-friendly” materials most suitable material for garden pavements in the context of the “carbon peaking and carbon neutrality” strategy, so as to provide the theoretical basis for the low-carbon emission reduction target of landscape architecture.
    Methods  This research selects 25 common garden pavement materials with different surface layers for calculation and evaluation of carbon emission. Firstly, the carbon emission accounting model is constructed based on the life cycle of garden pavement projects: the carbon emission factor method is adopted to calculate carbon emissions in such stages as material production, construction and transportation, maintenance and material recycling of garden pavement projects, during which the specific calculation parameters are mainly derived from the engineering practical experience, national standards and relevant research data. Secondly, after calculating the total amount of carbon emissions released during the life cycle of each type of garden pavement, the data are normalized by “carbon emission per square meter per year”, and the research results are obtained.
    Results/Conclusions  The analysis of the carbon emissions of 25 types of garden pavement materials over their respective life cycle shows that, among the 25 types of garden pavements, the three types with the highest carbon emissions over their life cycle are glued stone pavement, anti-corrosion wood pavement and limestone pavement, and the three types with the lowest emissions are concrete pavement, recycled aggregate concrete pavement and pressure film art flooring. And from the perspective of the unit area and average annual carbon emission of garden pavement, the three types of garden pavements with the highest carbon emission are glued stone pavement, permeable concrete block pavement and sand-based permeable brick pavement, and the three types with the lowest emission are recycled aggregate concrete pavement, pressure film art flooring and concrete pavement. Based on the above results, the garden pavement materials that meet the requirements of low-carbon emission reduction are derived, and the following strategies for low-carbon emission reduction of garden pavements are proposed. 1) Enhance the durability of surface materials. The amount of average annual carbon emissions of surface materials over the life cycle of such materials is closely related to their durability. Therefore, enhancing the durability of materials can help prolong the service life and reduce the period of replacement and maintenance, thus achieving better cost performance. 2) Emphasize the use of concrete. Concrete is the basic structure of other pavements, and can be used directly as a pavement surface, but adding ant other surface material on top of concrete may increase carbon emissions. 3) Prioritize the use of high-strength, thin materials for garden pavements. 4) Attach importance to the life span of surface materials. The life span of different surface materials has a greater impact on the average annual carbon emissions of pavements, even greater than the thickness of pavement structure and the average annual carbon emissions of materials themselves. 5) Minimize the use of glued stone pavement. Although glued stone pavement is rich in color and can be put together freely, the carbon emission of epoxy resin binder as a chemical product contained in glued stone pavement is more than 10 times higher than that of ordinary inorganic materials. 6) Maximize the use of granular pavement. Among the 25 types of pavements, granular pavement of graded gravel surface without cementation performs best in environmental adaption, environmental protection and low carbon, and thus can be vigorously promoted for use under appropriate conditions.

     

/

返回文章
返回