CN 11-5366/S     ISSN 1673-1530
“风景园林,不只是一本期刊。”

基于可解释机器学习与多目标优化算法的山区绿色基础设施格局优化——以北京市浅山区为例

Optimization of Green Infrastructure Patterns in Mountainous Areas Based on Interpretable Machine Learning and Multi-objective Optimization Algorithm: A Case Study of Shallow Mountainous Areas in Beijing

  • 摘要:
    目的 气候变化的加剧显著提升了浅山地区的洪涝风险。明晰绿色基础设施(green infrastructure, GI)空间格局特征对山地雨洪的作用机制,并优化其空间格局,可加强浅山区的洪涝防治能力,减轻极端降雨的消极影响。
    方法 1)通过SWAT软件与XGBoost机器学习模型,构建基于GI空间格局特征的高精度山地雨洪产流预测代理模型;2)使用基于SHAP的机器学习解释工具对该模型进行解释,定量揭示各类GI空间格局特征对山地雨洪产流的影响机制;3)基于影响机制,使用NSGA-Ⅱ多目标优化算法对浅山区典型区域内的关键GI进行格局优化,以检验GI格局优化的雨洪消减效果。
    结果 训练得出的山地雨洪产流预测模型拥有优秀的预测模拟性能。对该模型进行解释,发现郁闭落叶阔叶林的斑块密度以及草地的斑块面积比例是与山地雨洪产流正相关的关键格局特征;对二者进行优化的最优格局可在百年一遇的历史极端降雨情景下降低13.5%的洪涝风险。
    结论 本研究通过应用可解释机器学习技术,成功揭示了不同GI空间格局特征对山地雨洪产流的影响,并对关键格局特征的作用机制进行探讨,提出林地斑块联通、草地斑块缩小以促进最优GI格局的策略,减小强降雨下山地区域的洪涝风险。研究成果可为类似地区的山地绿色空间规划提供有效技术支持和实践指导。

     

    Abstract:
    Objective The intensification of climate change has led to a significant escalation in flood risk within shallow mountainous areas, posing a severe threat to human life, health, and ecological security. These transitional areas, often situated at the interface between mountainous terrain and urbanized plains, are uniquely vulnerable to the hydrological impacts of extreme precipitation. Existing research has established that green infrastructure (GI), through its influence on fundamental hydrological processes such as the rainfall – runoff and runoff – sediment relationships, can play a pivotal role in stormwater management. However, the current body of literature predominantly focuses on two main scales: the effectiveness of individual GI elements at the localized plot level and the impact of the broader green space matrix at the large basin scale. Consequently, a critical knowledge gap persists concerning the influence of the spatial configuration of GI patches — such as their shape, size, and degree of fragmentation — on hydrological responses at the finer, sub-basin scale, which is the most relevant scale for understanding flood generation. Clarifying the mechanisms through which GI spatial patterns affect mountainous stormwater runoff and subsequently optimizing these patterns are crucial steps toward enhancing the flood prevention and control capabilities of shallow mountainous areas. This research aims to bridge the knowledge gap by elucidating these mechanisms and developing an optimization framework to mitigate the adverse effects of extreme rainfall in the sensitive shallow mountainous areas.
    Methods This research adopts a two-stage research framework, comprising the two stages of mechanism exploration and pattern optimization. In the stage of exploration of hydrological mechanisms, two sample basins are selected within the shallow mountainous area of Beijing and, based on historical meteorological data and land cover data, the SWAT (soil and water assessment tool) model is used to simulate runoff generation in mountainous sub-basins with high spatiotemporal resolution. Meanwhile, machine learning methods, specifically an XGBoost-based model, are applied to the sample data to construct a high-accuracy predictive model for stormwater runoff generation, with a focus on GI spatial pattern characteristics as predictor variables. To interpret the machine learning results, the SHAP (SHapley Additive exPlanations) framework is employed to quantitatively elucidate the impact mechanisms of various GI spatial pattern metrics on mountainous stormwater runoff. In the pattern optimization stage, key GI spatial metrics are identified as optimization variables based on their hydrological influence. Under a dual-objective framework emphasizing both cost-effectiveness and flood mitigation efficacy, the NSGA-Ⅱ (nondominated sorting genetic algorithm Ⅱ) is used to optimize GI configuration for a representative shallow mountainous area. The effectiveness of these optimizations in reducing flood risks is validated through extreme historical rainfall scenarios.
    Results The resulting predictive model for mountainous runoff generation demonstrates excellent simulation and forecasting capabilities, especially in modeling the influence of GI spatial pattern changes on runoff processes in complex mountainous terrains. The interpretive analysis using SHAP on the trained model provides crucial insights into the underlying mechanisms. Among the numerous GI landscape metrics evaluated, two features emerge as the most critical drivers positively correlated with increased mountainous stormwater runoff: the patch density (PD) of closed-canopy deciduous broad-leaved forests and the percent of landscape (PLAND) occupied by grasslands. The analysis reveals that an increase in either of the aforesaid two metrics consistently contributes to higher predicted runoff volumes. In contrast, the spatial pattern characteristics of other vegetation types, such as closed-canopy evergreen coniferous forests and closed-canopy deciduous coniferous forests, are found with a comparatively weak and less significant influence on the hydrological response. During the multi-objective pattern optimization process, using the two most influential metrics (PD and PLAND) as adjustable variables for a typical area, the optimized spatial pattern is able to reduce flood risk by 13.5% under the scenario of once-in-a-century extreme rainfall.
    Conclusion The XGBoost machine learning model displays outstanding applicability for flood risk assessment and hydrological scenario simulation in shallow mountainous areas. An in-depth analysis of the GI spatial metrics identified by SHAP interpretation suggests that the fragmentation resulting from increased PD of closed-canopy deciduous broad-leaved forests, together with the impact of grassland PLAND on the runoff coefficient, are the core driving factors of stormwater runoff generation in these mountainous contexts. Additionally, the shape and configuration of grassland patches may further promote stormwater runoff. Accordingly, in the process of optimizing GI spatial arrangements in shallow mountainous areas, enhancing the connectivity of closed-canopy deciduous broad-leaved forest while reducing the size of large grassland patches is found conducive to forming optimal GI layouts that reduce flood risk under extreme precipitation. Through the application of interpretable machine learning techniques, this research reveals the underlying mechanisms by which different GI spatial pattern metrics influence mountain runoff generation and, based on these findings, effectively reduces regional flood risk during extreme rainfall events. The methodological approach and practical guidance provided by this research offer robust technical support for flood-mitigating green space planning in similar shallow mountain terrains and contribute valuable experience for regional adaptation to intensified climate-driven stormwater challenges.

     

/

返回文章
返回