CN 11-5366/S     ISSN 1673-1530
“风景园林,不只是一本期刊。”
毛华松,汤思琦,程语.基于地方志的中国风景遗产保护理论探索[J].风景园林,2023,30(12):56-65 doi: 10.12409/j.fjyl.202309120412.
引用本文: 毛华松,汤思琦,程语.基于地方志的中国风景遗产保护理论探索[J].风景园林,2023,30(12):56-65 doi: 10.12409/j.fjyl.202309120412.
MAO H S, TANG S Q, CHENG Y. Exploration of Protection Theory for Chinese Scenic Heritage Based on Local Chronicles[J]. Landscape Architecture, 2023, 30(12): 56-65 doi: 10.12409/j.fjyl.202309120412.
Citation: MAO H S, TANG S Q, CHENG Y. Exploration of Protection Theory for Chinese Scenic Heritage Based on Local Chronicles[J]. Landscape Architecture, 2023, 30(12): 56-65 doi: 10.12409/j.fjyl.202309120412.

基于地方志的中国风景遗产保护理论探索

Exploration of Protection Theory for Chinese Scenic Heritage Based on Local Chronicles

  • 摘要:
    目的  中国风景认知及实践具有鲜明的独特性。城乡风景的代际传承是普遍存在的客观事实,造就了中国本土特有的遗产类型——风景遗产。而当前风景遗产概念的泛化,导致相应保护实践的创新性不足。因而理清风景与风景遗产的概念与内涵,明晰风景遗产的保护对象及其代际传承中的方法、途径,可为中国风景遗产实践提供理论支持,为世界遗产地方转向贡献中国智慧。
    方法/过程  以记述时间跨度长、风景类型及数量丰富的古代绍兴为研究对象,以方志作为基本研究材料,基于文本分析、词频分析、案例统计、历史地理空间标注的方法,回溯古代风景实践,并进行文字及空间上的深描。
    结果/结论  总结了基于风景“自然人文关联性”的基本内涵特征与形态表征特征,结合风景遗产代际性与代表性特征的风景遗产识别方法,归纳了风景遗产在形成过程中,“名胜”与“形胜”、“人杰”与“地灵”的双向融合;在传承中,以儒家教化价值观为导向;在传播中,以景物的文化阐释和生活的途径来强化自然及人工物质要素和非物质精神的代际传承。风景遗产作为中国极为独特的遗产类型,在当前保护实践中应完善其标准、价值与内涵,积极吸收历史经验。

     

    Abstract:
    Objective  Scenic cognition and practice in China are of distinct uniqueness. In China, heritage with a long history and universal consensus, based on traditional ideas and practices such as “scenery view” and “scenery construction”, and guided by “scenery culture”, is a unique type of heritage — scenic heritage. Although there was no concept of heritage protection for “scenic heritage” in ancient China, the continuity and inheritance of scenic entities such as scenic spots, and historical sites all reflect the values of the ancients. Based on the principles of advocating ancient culture and literature, the ancients have carried out tangible maintenance and repair, as well as intangible written recording and cultural dissemination of related heritage. These scenic entities correspondingly exhibit basic characteristics of intergenerational and representative nature. However, in the current heritage protection system, a comprehensive theoretical system and corresponding heritage protection norms and measures have not yet been established for the protection of scenic heritage. As an academic concept, “scenic heritage” has not yet risen to a legal practice concept, and due to the differences in the background and the semantic meaning of “scenery” between China and foreign countries, and between ancient and modern times, the concept of scenic heritage has become more generalized, while the protection objects and scope of scenic heritage have become increasingly blurred, thus affecting the innovation of corresponding protection practice. Therefore, clarifying the concepts and connotations of “scenery” and “scenic heritage”, the protection objects of scenic heritage, and the methods and approaches for intergenerational inheritance of scenic heritage, can provide theoretical support for the practice of scenic heritage in China and contribute Chinese wisdom to the transformation of world heritage sites.
    Methods/process  In ancient times, Shaoxing was a secluded literary paradise with numerous celebrities and beautiful mountains and waters. The scenery and poetry elucidated from Kuaiji Prefecture became the origin of Chinese scenery construction and landscape poetry. In later generations, Shaoxing still boasts outstanding talents and a rich collection of cultural relics. It is a scenic spot with numerous historical landmarks and detailed local chronicles. Taking the ancient city of Shaoxing as an example and using local chronicles as basic research materials, this research traces ancient local chronicles following the above standards. Based on text analysis, word frequency analysis, case statistics, and historical geographical spatial annotation methods, this research traces ancient landscape practice and conducts in-depth textual and spatial descriptions to organize a list of ancient local scenic heritage, thus further exploring the characteristics of scenic heritage.
    Results/conclusion  By analyzing the concepts of scenery and scenic heritage, the research clarifies the positioning of the world heritage protection system for scenic heritage, and believes that scenic heritage should be a unique and interrelated cultural landscape in China. In the interrelated cultural landscape in western countries, most of the natural values are only related to religion or primitive natural worship, while relevant experiences and phenomena in China can greatly deepen and broaden the understanding of nature and humanity. Landscape heritage can break through the belief barriers of Western “religious and natural holy sites” in terms of associated images and ways, and condense multiple connotations such as philosophical ideas, literature and art, ethical aesthetics, and historical memory. Landscape heritage is featured by speculative thinking into nature, humanistic initiative, cultural profundity, aesthetic height, and extensive influence. Based on scenery’s basic connotation characteristics of natural and cultural correlation and morphological representation characteristics, this research establishes a scenic heritage identification method that integrates the intergenerational and representative characteristics of scenic heritage, in order to clarify the protection objects and scope of scenic heritage. Based on the case analysis of ancient Shaoxing, this research has local scenery divided into landscape scenery and artificial scenery, proposes the different formation characteristics and cognitive perspectives of scenic and physical heritage, and summarizes the dual core values of human and earth spirit in scenic heritage. In inheritance, guided by Confucian values, scenic heritage is closely related to famous sages, and has functions such as visiting scenic spots, offering great sacrifices to mountains and rivers, and public sightseeing. The construction, repair, and protection of scenic heritage are all led by local officials. In terms of dissemination, through case studies of scenic and scenic heritage sites in the form of Wolong Mountain and Orchid Pavilion in Shaoxing, this research summarizes the cultural interpretation of scenery construction in ancient scenic heritage protection, breaking through the pursuit of material authenticity in Western heritage protection, emphasizing spiritual resonance rather than material expression, and strengthening the intergenerational inheritance of natural and artificial material elements, and immaterial spirits through the way of scenic life. To better protect scenic heritage, a unique type of heritage in China, we should improve its protection standards, values, and connotations, and actively absorb historical experience.

     

/

返回文章
返回