Abstract: The 3D visualization evaluation of historic urban parks has practical demands and theoretical significance. However, there is a lack of researches. Based on visual argumentation, this paper constructs the 3D visualization evaluation framework from three aspects: logic, rhetoric and dialectic. It fixes the evaluation index factors and weight by adopting the Delphi expert investigation method and analytic hierarchy process to construct the 3D visualization evaluation system for historic urban parks. Citing Shanghai Fuxing Park as a case of empirical study, it uses the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method to conduct public evaluation and expert evaluation of the 3D visualization results of the scenes between 1926 and 1935 of the Fuxing Park, to test the feasibility of the evaluation system.