CN 11-5366/S     ISSN 1673-1530
“风景园林,不只是一本期刊。”
刘家琳,刘兆莉,张蕊.重庆示范性海绵型住区海绵系统长期水文-成本综合绩效优化[J].风景园林,2024,31(2):78-86.
引用本文: 刘家琳,刘兆莉,张蕊.重庆示范性海绵型住区海绵系统长期水文-成本综合绩效优化[J].风景园林,2024,31(2):78-86.
LIU J L, LIU Z L, ZHANG R. Optimization of Long-Term Comprehensive Hydrology-Cost Performance of the Demonstrative Spongy Residential Area in Chongqing[J]. Landscape Architecture, 2024, 31(2): 78-86.
Citation: LIU J L, LIU Z L, ZHANG R. Optimization of Long-Term Comprehensive Hydrology-Cost Performance of the Demonstrative Spongy Residential Area in Chongqing[J]. Landscape Architecture, 2024, 31(2): 78-86.

重庆示范性海绵型住区海绵系统长期水文-成本综合绩效优化

Optimization of Long-Term Comprehensive Hydrology-Cost Performance of the Demonstrative Spongy Residential Area in Chongqing

  • 摘要:
    目的 中国海绵城市建设已逐步进入优化营建与科学评估阶段。针对已建成海绵型住区,对于海绵系统的长期水文-成本综合绩效的研究较为欠缺。通过对长期水文、成本的量化评估,探讨亚热带季风性湿润气候地区中住区的海绵系统设计方式。
    方法 以重庆示范性海绵型住区为研究对象,构建现状水文模型,通过监测数据进行精准校验。以低成本为目标,采用雨水桶及少量生物滞留设施和渗透塘,设定比选方案S1;以高水文绩效为目标,采用生物滞留设施、雨水桶、渗渠、渗透塘、轻薄绿色屋顶等类型丰富的设施,设定比选方案S2。在校验模型基础上构建出比选方案的水文模型,量化评估各方案长期的水文绩效、成本投入及水文-成本综合绩效。
    结果 现状方案的年径流总量控制率为75.3%,略低于规划控制目标,且海绵系统建造维护成本相对最高。S1的平均年径流总量控制率为87.2%,其海绵系统的总投入成本最低。S2的平均年径流总量控制率和峰值削减率最优,其长期水文-成本综合绩效相对现状方案提升3.6倍。其中,透水铺装和蓄水池的水文-成本综合绩效最低,雨水桶与渗渠组合的综合绩效最高。
    结论 提出在不同应用条件下,住区适宜采用的不同海绵系统设计方式。当住区绿地率条件良好,对水文-成本综合绩效要求较高时,宜采用具有丰富设施类型的S2。对重庆以及有相似降雨条件的亚热带季风性湿润气候地区中海绵型住区的建设优化有积极参考价值。

     

    Abstract:
    Objective The General Office of the Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development clearly proposed that the construction of sponge city should focus on the integration of multiple objectives, emphasize the optimization of life cycle design, and advocate scientific hydrological performance evaluation of completed projects, which requires us to focus on built-up areas, build a more suitable and economical sponge facility system with higher comprehensive performance and establish and improve the evaluation mechanism for construction performance of sponge city, so as to usher sponge city into the construction optimization and scientific evaluation stage. According to the pilot requirements of sponge city, more than 80% of the built-up areas need to reach the sponge city construction target by 2030. In this context, the number of spongy residential areas, which apply the concept of sponge city to build sponge facilities to achieve the target requirements of runoff control, is on the rise. At present, there is a lack of research on long-term hydrologic performance evaluation of spongy residential areas in China. Most researches focus on hydrological performance under short-term rainfall scenarios, or on the elaboration of sponge technology design methods for completed projects. Besides, the verification process of hydrology model in the research on spongy residential areas is relatively lacking. Most researches adopt the outflow monitoring data spanning 1-2 short rainfall periods for model verification, so the verification results may be accidental. It is necessary to adopt the outflow monitoring data spanning multiple long rainfall periods for model verification, so as to improve the reliability of model results. In addition, there is a lack of post-evaluation of the cost consumption of sponge systems in completed projects in China. There are few researches on how to reduce the construction and maintenance cost of sponge system in residential areas. The aim of this research is to explore the design approach for typical sponge systems for residential areas in regions with subtropical monsoon humid climate through the quantitative evaluation of long-term hydrology-cost performance.
    Methods Taking the demonstrative spongy residential area in Chongqing as the research object, this research adopts EPA Storm Water Management Model 5.1 to build the current hydrological model. Modeling parameters include hydrological parameters of the underlying surface in the catchment area, parameters of the drainage pipe network, and structural parameters of sponge facilities. The model is accurately verified using monitoring data, and Nash-sutcliffe efficiency coefficient is used to test the matching degree between the monitored runoff value and the simulated model value. The data from rain gauges set around the residential area (stable data from April to October 2018) and the discharge monitoring data corresponding to the rainfall events of the residential area are used to select events with rainfall duration of more than 6 hours for parameter calibration and model verification. After parameter calibration, the monitoring data of typical rainfall events is selected and input into the model to verify the simulation results. The results reveal that the ENS and R2 values are both above 0.75, indicating a high matching degree between the simulation results and the monitoring results, and that the current hydrological model is reliable. In order to explore the optimization model of sponge system design for typical residential green space, the research adopts two sponge system comparison schemes S1 and S2 (the current sponge system scheme is S0), with a view to improving the hydrology-cost performance of the sponge system. Both S1 and S2 are expected to achieve higher hydrological performance and lower cost than S0. On the basis of the current hydrological model already monitored and verified, the sponge system is reset according to S1 and S2 schemes. The hydrological model of the selected schemes is constructed to quantitatively evaluate the long-term hydrological performance, cost input and comprehensive hydrology-cost performance of each scheme.
    Results The results show that the total annual runoff control rate of the current scheme is 75.3%, which is slightly lower than the planning control target, and the construction and maintenance cost of the current sponge system is almost the highest. As to scheme S1, the average annual runoff total control rate is 87.2%, the peak reduction efficiency is slightly lower than the current scheme, and the total input cost of the sponge system is the lowest. As to scheme S2, the average annual runoff total control rate is the best, reaching 89.7%, the peak reduction rate of rainstorm (80.3 mm) is 92.8%, and the long-term comprehensive hydrology-cost performance is 3.6 times higher than the current scheme.
    Conclusion Based on the results above, this research proposes a suitable design approach for sponge facility system in residential areas under different application conditions. Specifically, scheme S0 is more suitable for application in residential areas with high green land rate, low requirements for annual runoff control rate, high requirements for rainwater resource recycling, and high investment cost. S1 is suitable for application in residential areas with relatively limited land use but still with certain green space conditions, and in projects with high requirements for annual runoff control rate and tight cost input. S2 is suitable for application in residential areas with certain green space conditions, and in projects with high requirements for comprehensive hydrology-cost performance. The aforesaid design approach can well balance the requirements of hydrological control and landscape diversity in an economical and efficient manner. The results of this research have positive reference value for the construction optimization of spongy residential areas in Chongqing and other subtropical humid areas with similar precipitation conditions.

     

/

返回文章
返回